Pay-By-Procedure or Pay-By-Visit: Which Model Fits Your Trial?
Pay-By-Procedure or Pay-By-Visit: Which Model Fits Your Trial?

Choosing the right site payment structure improves efficiency, predictability, and financial transparency. Paying a research site that participates in a clinical trial “by procedure” for work completed is complicated, but fair and transparent, and if done correctly can be equally as efficient and accurate as pay-by-visit.
Historically, the industry relies heavily on the Pay-by-Visit model. In this setup, a site is compensated a flat, predetermined fee whenever a site reports the required data for a scheduled visit. Conversely, many trials would be better suited for the Pay-by-Procedure (or hybrid) model. This methodology ties compensation directly to the specific data points or procedures successfully captured and entered (often triggered directly by Electronic Data Capture or EDC systems).
This post dives into the following:
- Pros and Cons of paying Sites by procedure vs flat fee per visit
- Discuss when to use one or the other
The choice between pay-by-procedure and pay-by-visit depends on various factors, including whether visit procedures are required or optional, complexity of protocol design, and requirements for data output from an EDC. For a detailed analysis of an actual study click here.


Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the main difference between the Pay-by-Visit and Pay-by-Procedure models?
A: The primary difference lies in how compensation is triggered and calculated:
- Pay-by-Visit: Sites are paid a flat, predetermined fee whenever they report the required data for a scheduled visit.
- Pay-by-Procedure: Compensation is tied directly to the specific data points or procedures that are successfully captured and entered, which is often triggered by Electronic Data Capture (EDC) systems.
Q: What are the benefits of using a Pay-by-Procedure model?
A: While it is more complex, the Pay-by-Procedure model offers several distinct advantages:
- Transparency and Accuracy: It is a fair, transparent, and accurate system where every procedure has a defined cost and a clear, verifiable payment trigger.
- Automation: It automates payments, saving time for all parties involved.
- Timely Data Entry: It incentivizes sites to enter data promptly because they are paid as the underlying data is completed.
- Cost Avoidance: The financial savings and cost avoidance gained from this model can far outweigh the initial investment.
Q: What makes the Pay-by-Procedure model difficult to implement?
A: The model’s primary drawbacks stem from its complexity. A single visit can contain 10 to 15 line items, and Clinical Trial Agreements (CTAs) may contain hundreds of line items—all requiring unique costs and payment triggers. Furthermore, it requires systems to be integrated to feed data, requires specific EDC functionality and database design, and can make financial accruals difficult to track if it’s unclear whether a procedure was skipped or data entry is just delayed.
Q: When should a trial sponsor choose Pay-by-Visit over Pay-by-Procedure?
A: The Pay-by-Visit model is best utilized when it is expected that all procedures must be completed on each visit. It is a less complex, industry-standard setup that offers highly predictable, fixed costs for each visit.
Conversely, you should opt for Pay-by-Procedure if the visits contain optional procedures that may not always occur, or if the financial cost avoidance outweighs the added technical complexity.
About Block Clinical
Block Clinical provides site and patient centric solutions that centralize management of site and patient payments, travel and logistics. We proactively administer approved travel logistics, lowering out-of-pocket expenses and eliminating the time a site or patient would spend arranging on-own.
Interested in partnering or learning more?
Contact us at info@blockclinical.com or visit blockclinical.com to explore how we’re shaping the future of clinical research.